[Opinion] Sumsung vs Apple


Samsung, Enough Already!

I guess I have something to get off my
chest about the Apple vs. Samsung dispute. 
I can’t consider myself an insider but I did live “that life” for a
while.  I worked at Palm and Palmsource
(the Palm OS company) while the smartphone revolution was just getting started
and I watched as all the industry players were setting their course. 

I’ve visited Nokia in Helsinki during the
dead of winter when you only get about 3 hours of daylight because you are so
far away from the equator; I’ve been to Samsung in Suwon where their cafeteria
manages to feed tens of thousands of factory workers during a lunch hour frenzy
that is so well orchestrated that the cafeteria should be classified as a
factory too; I’ve met with Ericsson (does anyone even remember who these guys
are?); I’ve even met HT Cho, who tried to convince me that HTC stands for “high
tech computer” when I joked with him about naming a company after his own
initials, long before they thought about using Android to become a smartphone

Apple was not even a maybe, not even a
dark horse back in those days.  And then,
in 2007, that all changed.  Apple went
from ZERO products or phone market share to launching the hottest product lines
in the space and creating a tsunami wave of customers who helped drive them to become
the new leader in the space.

I’m reminded of the words from one of my
mentors, Jim Rohn.  He equates
opportunity and difficulty to the wind that blows a sailboat along the sea.  He says that the same winds blow on us all
(the economic, political, and social environments, etc) so it’s not the wind
that determines where one ends up in life, it’s the set of the sail.

Understand this, Apple started with NOTHING.  They didn’t make PDAs that
morphed into phones (like Palm); they didn’t have a vast product line of “dumb”
phones from which to build upon (like Samsung and Nokia, etc); they didn’t
invent and manage the cell phone tower technology (like Ericsson and
Motorola).  Apple had just a small group
of innovative engineers and designers who were obsessed with creating a new
paradigm for how to interface with your phone, both through its design aesthetics
and through it’s intuitive software. 

They were able to think so far outside the box as to create the first
generation iPhone with an entirely new approach to industrial design of the
hardware to the software and user navigation. 
Apple wouldn’t even let AT&T sell it through their channel; you were
an Apple customer and had to go to them for all purchases and support.  This had never been done before!  It was unimaginably ingenious and nobody had
seen it coming.  Certainly nobody believed
that a non-player like Apple would generate such an earthquake in the phone


In 2007 all the players I mentioned above
and the many others that I didn’t mention all collectively said “Crap, this
iPhone thing is a game-changer.”  So
Samsung’s best response was to copy what Apple was doing in hardware and
product design?  I’m not surprised at the
iPhone knockoffs by the Taiwan and Chinese “cloners” who have been at it for
decades, but frankly, I expect more from Samsung.

Enough already, Samsung.  Stop your crying and complaining.  Get innovating.  Apple came into a market where you were
dominating and ate your lunch by out innovating you.  They didn’t copy your designs to get
there.  Just admit the loss and move
on.  You make everything from
refrigerators to ocean liners, from televisions to photocopiers.  Surely you have more resources at your
fingertips than Apple.  Get back to work
and create something stunning of your own design!  The world is waiting. 

-Mark (just my 2 cents)


3 thoughts on “[Opinion] Sumsung vs Apple

  1. Bill Hilton August 27, 2012 / 9:10 pm

    Yes, Mark, I could hardly agree more with your 2 cents.


  2. eric August 29, 2012 / 5:04 am

    Great post Mark, Yes, The Newton was also ahead but a plodder, they were just beginning, Samsung should be ashamed


  3. Jonathan September 1, 2012 / 6:58 pm

    Excellent points, Mark. I realized this: I wanted an iPhone with a bigger screen so I bought a Samsung. Transition has been pretty easy which is an indication of how similar the devices are.
    Samsung makes all of the pieces and could hold the best screens and best ICs for themselves. They’ve launched a ton of phones in many form factors so they should know where the consumers want them to deliver product. Now they need to put the pieces together in a unique and compelling way.
    This will definitely be interesting to watch!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s